Arcaro's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

At Arcaro's Pizza, you find a family-owned gem nestled atop Taylors Hill. For over four decades, this spot has been the go-to for fresh, handcrafted Italian staples. Their dough, made daily with the same passion and secret recipes dating back to the 1980s, forms the perfect foundation for their legendary pizzas. The menu features a variety of choices, from classic cheese and pepperoni to inventive specialty pies like white pizza and Mexican pizza, each crafted with quality ingredients and attention to detail.

The restaurant caters to all, including kids with a dedicated menu. Whether you savor a hot hoagie, a hearty pasta dish, or an Italian-style salad, Arcaro’s keeps flavor front and center. They also offer quick takeout and delivery options, making it convenient to enjoy your favorites whether dining solo or with family. With prices ranging from $10 to $20, every meal provides excellent value without sacrificing quality. Stop by or call today to experience the irresistible aroma and taste that make Arcaro’s a cornerstone of Scranton’s food scene.

Arcaro's Pizza Menu image 1
Arcaro's Pizza Menu image 2
Arcaro's Pizza

Arcaro's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Step inside Arcaro’s Pizza, and you’re greeted by a casual, cozy atmosphere that welcomes families, groups, and solo diners alike. The warm decor and quiet environment make it perfect for a relaxed dinner. The dining room features comfortable seating, wheelchair-accessible spaces, and a friendly staff eager to recommend their favorites. The visible pizza oven gives a sense of authenticity, and the aroma of freshly baked dough fills the air—an instant mood lifter. Whether enjoying a slice at the bar with a great beer selection or sharing a hearty family platter in the dining area, you get a taste of community and comfort.

The establishment also offers a quick, friendly takeaway service for those on the go. With its family-friendly vibe and dedication to quality, Arcaro’s remains a local favorite where every visit feels like dining at a relative’s house—warm, inviting, and full of delicious surprises.

Arcaro's Pizza

About Arcaro's Pizza Food and Specialties

Arcaro’s Pizza excels in creating authentic Italian dishes with a local twist. Their signature feature is their fresh-made dough, crafted daily to ensure a perfect crunch and chew in every slice. The menu highlights include their standout specialty pizzas—like their Mexican pizza, which combines seasoned toppings with crispy crust, and their unique white pizza that boasts a creamy garlic sauce and fresh toppings. Specialties extend to their hearty pasta dishes, such as spaghetti with meatballs or sausage, and a variety of satisfying platters like breaded shrimp or tripe, which they are renowned for.

The restaurant also prides itself on its triage of comfort foods, hot open-faced sandwiches, and a kids’ menu that keeps the whole family satisfied. Their commitment to quality ingredients, local flavors, and consistent recipes from the ‘80s makes every dish a nostalgic yet fresh experience. It’s a place where tradition meets taste, and every bite tells a story of family and community.

Arcaro's Pizza

At Arcaro’s, we are committed to preserving authentic Italian flavors and maintaining high standards in every dish we serve. Our specialty pizzas, including our celebrated white pizza and custom creations, showcase our dedication to culinary excellence.

Our vision centers on community and family. We strive to be more than just a restaurant—we want to be a gathering place where neighbors meet, families create memories, and food connects us all.

Our focus on quality ingredients, traditional recipes, and friendly service exemplifies this mission.

We aim to innovate without losing our roots, introducing unique offerings like our famous tripe and specialty hoagies while honoring the classics. Sustainability, community engagement, and bringing joy through great food remain central to our goals. Every pizza, pasta, and salad reflects our passion and respect for Italian culinary heritage—made for the community that has supported us for over 40 years.